Head to Head

Shake ShackvsFive Guys

Side-by-side price comparison across 28 NYC neighborhoods.

S

Shake Shack

fast-casual

$7.89

avg across 28 neighborhoods

9 menu items

F

Five Guys

fast-food

$10.29

avg across 28 neighborhoods

10 menu items

Price by Neighborhood

Astoria

Shake Shack

$7.57

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$9.87

Bay Ridge

Shake Shack

$7.26

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$9.45

Bushwick

Shake Shack

$7.50

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$9.76

Chelsea

Shake Shack

$8.21

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$10.69

Crown Heights

Shake Shack

$7.42

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$9.66

Dumbo

Shake Shack

$7.97

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$10.69

East Village

Shake Shack

$7.89

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$10.28

Financial District

Shake Shack

$8.15

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$10.58

Flushing

Shake Shack

$7.34

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$9.56

Forest Hills

Shake Shack

$7.50

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$9.76

Gramercy

Shake Shack

$8.13

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$10.58

Greenpoint

Shake Shack

$7.81

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$10.17

Harlem

Shake Shack

$7.34

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$9.56

Hell's Kitchen

Shake Shack

$8.28

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$10.79

Jackson Heights

Shake Shack

$7.42

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$9.66

Long Island City

Shake Shack

$7.97

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$10.38

Lower East Side

Shake Shack

$7.73

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$10.07

Midtown East

Shake Shack

$8.23

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$11.10

Midtown West

Shake Shack

$8.36

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$10.89

Murray Hill

Shake Shack

$8.05

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$10.48

Park Slope

Shake Shack

$7.89

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$10.28

SoHo

Shake Shack

$8.28

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$10.79

Times Square

Shake Shack

$8.68

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$11.31

Tribeca

Shake Shack

$8.44

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$10.99

Upper East Side

Shake Shack

$8.28

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$10.79

Upper West Side

Shake Shack

$8.02

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$10.48

Washington Heights

Shake Shack

$7.10

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$9.25

Williamsburg

Shake Shack

$7.97

Cheaper
VS

Five Guys

$10.38

Shake Shack — Menu Items

Cheese Fries

Washington Heights$5.39Bay Ridge$5.51Flushing$5.57Harlem$5.57Jackson Heights$5.63+23 more

Chicken Shack

Washington Heights$8.63Bay Ridge$8.82Harlem$8.92Flushing$8.92Jackson Heights$9.01+25 more

Concrete

Washington Heights$6.20Bay Ridge$6.34Harlem$6.41Flushing$6.41Jackson Heights$6.48+23 more

Fries

Midtown East$4.49Dumbo$4.49

Hot Dog

Washington Heights$4.76Bay Ridge$4.87Flushing$4.92Harlem$4.92Crown Heights$4.97+23 more

Lemonade

Washington Heights$3.50Bay Ridge$3.58Harlem$3.62Flushing$3.62Crown Heights$3.66+23 more

Shack Stack

Washington Heights$11.24Bay Ridge$11.49Harlem$11.62Flushing$11.62Jackson Heights$11.74+23 more

ShackBurger

Washington Heights$7.55Bay Ridge$7.72Upper West Side$7.79Harlem$7.80Flushing$7.80+27 more

SmokeShack

Washington Heights$9.53Bay Ridge$9.74Flushing$9.85Harlem$9.85Jackson Heights$9.95+23 more

Five Guys — Menu Items

Bacon Cheeseburger

Washington Heights$15.11Bay Ridge$15.45Harlem$15.61Flushing$15.61Crown Heights$15.78+23 more

Cajun Fries

Washington Heights$5.84Bay Ridge$5.97Flushing$6.04Harlem$6.04Crown Heights$6.10+23 more

Cheeseburger

Washington Heights$13.55Bay Ridge$13.86Flushing$14.01Harlem$14.01Crown Heights$14.16+23 more

Grilled Cheese

Washington Heights$8.09Bay Ridge$8.27Harlem$8.36Flushing$8.36Crown Heights$8.45+23 more

Hamburger

Washington Heights$12.58Bay Ridge$12.86Harlem$13.00Flushing$13.00Jackson Heights$13.14+23 more

Hot Dog

Washington Heights$7.19Bay Ridge$7.35Harlem$7.43Flushing$7.43Jackson Heights$7.51+23 more

Little Hamburger

Washington Heights$8.99Bay Ridge$9.19Flushing$9.29Harlem$9.29Jackson Heights$9.39+23 more

Milkshake

Washington Heights$7.19Bay Ridge$7.35Harlem$7.43Flushing$7.43Jackson Heights$7.51+23 more

Regular Fries

Washington Heights$5.84Bay Ridge$5.97Harlem$6.04Flushing$6.04Crown Heights$6.10+23 more

Veggie Sandwich

Washington Heights$8.09Bay Ridge$8.27Harlem$8.36Flushing$8.36Crown Heights$8.45+23 more